Tag: Scott G2

Review of the Scott G2 905-4 (Part II)

gear bagCan’t really comment too much about the performance of this rod, other than give it a big thumbs up!

The whole setup is light as a feather…so light that a colleague thought it was a 3wt when they gave it a try. And that is good, particular for a kid (me) who learned to trout fish high-sticking a small East Coast tailwater and still can’t shake the tendency to lift the rod.

Casting

I ran this getup through it’s paces long tossing streamers into the stream spillout on a local reservoir. It handled beautifully with all but the largest beadhead woolies, running in tandem at that. Then the rod showed me it wasn’t an 8wt designed to throw large flies 75+ feet. Despite being a medium-action rod, it still had the backbone to pick up 20+ feet of line, and get it moving in another direction – that felt good.

I also tossed some attractor patterns up against some far banks one morning. Despite still not having a very good feel for the set up, and snagging a few times behind and to the right of me, it didn’t take long to figure out how to tighten up the loops and start dropping dries within inches of dirt. As a side note, I also found the tip just soft enough to mend away without shaking the leader in the slightest.

Catching (the important stuff)

I generally brag a lot about the fact that a lose very few fish post-hookup. But over the last three days I lost plenty. I am not going to blame the rod for this – it is a medium action – it’s just that the user is “over action.” I popped a lot of small tippets, and I think that was a trust issue. Enough said. Still, it is capable of catching fish, and I suspect it could catch a lot more in more capable hands:

healthy-rainbow-on-new-rig

I’d really love to sandbag the rating here to keep Scott on it’s toes, but I just can’t. I’ll get very use to this rod much sooner than later, especially as a result of it’s overly comforting weight factor.

I’m giving it a 9 out of 10 in the performance bracket, subject to further review and a possible upgrade.

Cheers.

UPDATE: Fly Fishing Insider just posted some benchmarks on 5-weight rods – the Scott G2 905/4 was not included.

Review of the Scott G2 905/4 (Part I)

gear bagEvery fishing fanatic needs some new gear every now and again, and I’m no different. My present quiver was purchased between 1997 and 1999, so I thought the time had come.

My choice was a trout rod, slightly lighter than model I presently carry for general duty. After a few weeks of research and a bit of touch and feel, I chose a Scott G2 in a 5-weight…the 4-piece job. Everyone said I made a good choice, but then again, the ones talking were either selling me the rod or going fishing with me this weekend, so I thought I’d throw in my own two cents.

This review is coming in two parts; the first will be aesthetics, which many people find very important (if all the gear everyone wears on the river is any indication), and the second will be performance on water (which is not really what I care about – it is all about looking good – but I’ll humor you).

The rod was ordered last Sunday from Western Rivers Flyfishers in Salt Lake City, Utah (a damn fine bunch of folks over there, IMHO), and arrived on my doorstep yesterday. So here we go (and keep in mind, this review is not being done by a pro – I am a rank amatuer and plan on staying that way)…

Part I – Build and Finish

The rod comes in a nicely constructed tube, which will take a place in the back of the closet when I stuff this puppy in my homemade multi-rod bag. I did note that the tube cap screws on nicely, as compared to the old Sage tubes I ditched long ago:

new-scott-g2-rod-tube

new-scott-g2-rod-tube-1

The cloth is pretty sweet too (as if anyone cares about tubes OR cloth):

Scott rod cloth

Scott rod cloth

Now, for the rod – four fine pieces:

Scott G2

Scott G2

I found no blemishes anywhere on the finish of any of the sections. It is a natural finish, meaning heavy on graphite ribs and very light on epoxy. All the guides were set in place very nicely, with smooth, tight wraps; error free and epoxied flawlessly as well. The corked was initially covered in plastic wrapping, which is of course now in the can – the cork was epoxied over the top quarter-inch, I guess for protection – a nice touch.

The ferrules are the internal kind, and are designed for long wear. This means you don’t need to try jamming them completely together; instead they come out of the womb with a quarter-inch or so gap intended when you put the rod pieces together. Over time, the fit will likely become a bit less snug and the sections will draw ever closer together, but I suspect that will be a long time (unless you are prone to leaving fly rods in door jams). I wax my ferrules every now and then to ensure smooth put-together and breakdown, and on this rod it was no different. The ferrules were dry, and now they are not.

Scott G2 ferrules

Overall, this little joker is a beauty, but I did find one little flaw. The reel seat was slightly misaligned from the fly eye (or whatever the hell techies call it), and this carried on to the first alignment dot on the butt section:

Scott fly catch

The above pic was taken while holding the rod, with reel seated and upright/perpendicular to the floor.

A minor issue, for me in particular, since I don’t pay much attention to those little alignment dots anyway (and the alignment was fine on the other three sections). Inclusive of this “tropical depression,” the rod gets a 9 out of 10 for build quality and appearance.

By the way, this addition to the rod bag was married to a Lamson/Waterworks Velocity 1.5 wrapped with an SA Mastery WF taper (Trout, to be exact, in olive).

Seated, the whole setup is very light and feels well balanced in my hand:

new-scott-g2-with-lamson

I found the exact balance point three-quarters of an inch below the top of the cork, if that makes any difference to anyone.

And here is a close-up of the bride, pre-ceremony:

Velocity reel

Velocity reel

I did get this rod out in the yard, after the nuptials. A few false casts, with tissue-laden leader end barely touching the tree across the street, and a nice loop carrying over the top of the car parked in the driveway next door. Feels smooth so far, although keeping that new line from landing on the blacktop and/or the windshield was a chore.

Part II, the real meat (or fish) of the issue, is coming up at the end of the weekend.